Wooden Toys vs Plastic Toys: The Smarter, Safer, and More Sustainable Choice for Babies
- thrivebaby9
- 21 hours ago
- 7 min read
As a mom who has seen both a baby and a preschooler grow through play, I’ve tested everything — from flashing plastic walkers to timeless wooden blocks. Here’s what I’ve learned (and what research says) about how material choice affects your baby’s brain, senses, and environment.
Table of Contents
The toys we choose for our babies shape how our little ones learn, explore, and connect. As parents, we often face the “wooden vs plastic toys” debate. Wooden toys look aesthetic and eco-friendly, while plastic ones are colorful and engaging. But which truly supports your baby’s learning through play?
Let’s explore the differences based on science, sustainability, and real mom experience.
How Material Type Affects a Baby’s Play and Brain Development
Toy materials influence how babies interact, focus, and learn.
Wooden toys tend to invite open-ended play — your baby must push, pull, or imagine how to use it.
Plastic toys often come with predefined actions — push a button, get a sound.
This affects how babies think and explore: wooden toys promote imagination and problem-solving; plastic toys often provide instant feedback and sensory stimulation.
The Wooden Toy Advantage
What Makes Wooden Toys Special
Wooden toys are naturally biodegradable, eco-friendly, and non-toxic when sourced right. They’re often made using sustainable wood and vegetable or water-based paints — aligning beautifully with Montessori principles of simplicity and real-world learning.
Pros of Wooden Toys
🌱 Eco-friendly & safe: No BPA, phthalates, or harmful chemicals.
🧠 Promotes creativity: Encourages imagination, cause-and-effect understanding, and problem-solving.
🖐️ Rich sensory feedback: Babies feel real textures and natural wood grains — more calming and grounding than overstimulating plastic.
🕰️ Durable & timeless: Can be passed down for generations — true heirloom toys.
💬 Encourages parent interaction: You often play with your baby, enhancing bonding and language development.
Cons of Wooden Toys
💧 Can get damaged by moisture or mold if not cared for properly.
🎨 Some painted toys may chip if low quality — always buy from reputable brands.
💸 Slightly higher upfront cost, but lasts longer (so cheaper long term).
How to Care for Wooden Toys
Wipe clean with a dry or damp cloth — no soaking or bleach.
Store in dry paper bags with silica gel to prevent moisture damage.
Condition occasionally with olive oil, beeswax, or jojoba oil for shine and longevity.
Avoid direct sunlight or water exposure for long periods.
The Plastic Toy Perspective
Why Plastic Toys Still Have a Place
Let’s be real — as a busy mom, plastic toys have saved my sanity. Whether it’s a budget-friendly Baby Einstein walker to help my infant practice sitting, standing and walking, or Magna-Tiles sparking creative STEM play for my preschooler — they do serve a purpose.
Pros of Plastic Toys
💦 Perfect for bath or outdoor play: Easy to wash and dry.
💰 Budget-friendly: Wide variety of affordable toys for every stage.
🧩 STEM & pretend play options: Great variety for toddlers and preschoolers.
🎨 Bright colors: Great for visual stimulation (also to keep them engaged while I can get some chores done!)
Cons of Plastic Toys
⚠️ Potential chemical exposure: Even BPA-free plastics can leach chemicals if low quality.
🧷 Breakable: Can crack into small hazardous pieces.
🌎 Environmental impact: Non-biodegradable and contributes to waste.
⏳ Short-lived: Often replaced quickly due to damage or disinterest.
What the Research Says
One of the strongest and most consistent findings in early childhood research is the value of open-ended play materials — toys that don’t have one fixed purpose or a “correct” way to play. These often align with simpler wooden toys rather than flashy, battery-operated plastic ones that limit how a child can engage.
According to the National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC),
“These toys are relatively open-ended, so children can use them in multiple ways. Also, they have all been around for a long time.”
Similarly, a PMC study found that such materials “encourage imagination and problem-solving skills.”
As far as safety is concerned, experts at Seattle Children’s Hospital recommend favoring wooden toys for younger children, explaining that “wood toys avoid plastics that can disrupt normal development at a critical age.” Soft, squeezable plastic bath toys, for instance, can leach chemicals when heated. Choosing non-toxic, BPA-free, or sustainably sourced options reduces this risk.
Even so, economist Emily Oster reminds parents that “there isn’t research proving wooden toys are inherently better.” The takeaway: while wooden toys encourage open-ended, sensory-rich play, a thoughtful mix of safe, high-quality wooden and plastic toys gives your baby the best of both worlds — imaginative learning and practicality.
Best Wooden Toy Brands (Tried, Trusted, and Loved)
Hape
One of my long-time favorites, Hape is a brand known for using sustainable materials like FSC-certified wood and bamboo. Their toys are simple, open-ended, and beautifully made.
Our Hape 5-sided activity cube has survived from the sitting stage right through preschool — over five years of play! My older one loved the Pound and Tap Bench as a toddler — she’d create her own little “concerts.” Now, my infant loves rolling the Raindrop Stick and watching the beads cascade inside.
Haba
Haba is another brand I trust for safe, eco-friendly play. They use water-based paints and premium materials. Their My Very First Games: Fishing Game was my daughter’s first introduction to magnetic play — and it’s still one of her favorites. This time around, I’ve picked the Haba Rainbow Sorter for my baby to explore colors and shapes — a big upgrade from the plastic one we had before that broke quickly.
Plan Toys
Plan Toys has set the standard for sustainable play — using chemical-free rubberwood, organic pigments, and formaldehyde-free glue. Their Alligator Pull Toy is a hit in our home — my older one pulls it around the house while my baby gleefully army-crawls behind, laughing. Plan Toys is a popular reputable brand for big reasons.
KiwiCo
For parents looking for a more affordable but equally thoughtful option, KiwiCo (a U.S.-based company) offers fantastic STEM and Montessori-inspired kits. Their infant and toddler play kits are high-quality and beautifully designed — a great alternative to Lovevery at a lower price point.
Manhattan Toy Company
Manhattan Toy Company is another U.S.-based brand I’ve come to rely on. Their toys have certified, safe manufacturing partners and are made to last. Their rattle and motor activity toys are simple, well-balanced, and perfect for babies who love to grasp, shake, and explore.
Grimms
If you’re drawn to open-ended, colorful designs, Grimms wooden toys are magical. Their famous rainbow stackers and Seven Friends in Bowls sets are perfect for building creativity, spatial reasoning, and fine motor skills — and they’re painted with non-toxic, saliva-resistant colors.
Tender Leaf Toys
Tender Leaf Toys uses reclaimed rubberwood to make sustainable, imaginative playsets — from pretend kitchens to shops and puzzles. Their focus on role play makes them perfect for developing language and social-emotional skills. Their first wooden jigsaw puzzle was a repeat hit with both of my kids.
Bumbu Toys
Bumbu Toys creates handcrafted heirloom-quality pieces that blend art, nature, and play. Their Montessori-style figurines are wonderful for storytelling, sorting, and imaginative play — and honestly, beautiful enough to decorate the nursery. Each piece feels unique, inviting slower, more mindful play.
Everwood Friends
For locally made, long-lasting toys, Everwood Friends crafts stunning wooden blocks and sets from domestic hard maple right here in the USA. Their Classic Wooden Alphabet Blocks are timeless and support early literacy, fine motor, and cooperative play.
Grapat
Grapat, a small family-run company, crafts stunning open-ended toys from sustainable wood and natural vegetable dyes. Their mandala sets and loose-part collections spark creativity, pattern recognition, and calm, focused play. Each set feels almost meditative in the way it engages children. This 4-piece wooden set with goose is one of the popular ones to get an idea of the brand. You can find a beautiful range of Grapat toys at trusted retailers like Bella Luna Toys (www.BellaLunaToys.com).
Best Plastic Toy Brands (Safe, Durable & Loved by Kids)
Green Toys
Green Toys tops my list for plastic brands that are truly eco-conscious. They’re made in the USA from 100% recycled materials, dishwasher-safe, and incredibly durable. From their Tugboat that sails through every bath to the Tea Set that’s been through countless pretend parties — these are plastic toys I never feel guilty about.
Lego
Lego is another long-term investment. Their efforts toward sustainability — like plant-based plastics — make them a better choice than ever. My daughter started with the Lego Classic Building Blocks as a toddler, and now at four, she’s obsessed with her Moana and Frozen playsets.
Melissa & Doug
Although known for their wooden line, Melissa & Doug also offer some great durable pretend-play sets. We got their 25-piece Doctor Kit as a 2-year birthday gift and I found that it was far more detailed and superior in quality than the 7-piece Fisher-price Doctor Set I had got her at a younger age for around the same price!
Brio
Brio strikes a great balance by combining wood and plastic in their high-quality STEM and building toys. Their builder sets and farm railway sets are classics that promote problem-solving, creativity, and fine motor skills.
Magna-Tiles and Picasso Tiles
These two brands deserve a shared spotlight for magnetic STEM play. They’re nearly indestructible, spark endless creativity, and grow with your child from toddler to school age. We use ours for everything from towers to color sorting — a total win for open-ended play.
Mattel
Among larger global brands, Mattel has taken major steps toward sustainability. Their Barbie Loves the Ocean line uses plastic made from 90% recycled ocean-bound plastic, while Mega Bloks Green Town playsets use plant-based materials. Their Hot Wheels continues to produce safe, non-toxic toys that meet U.S. and EU safety standards. The T-Rex Car Track Set is my daughter’s favorite — perfect for collaborative and imaginative play with friends. It’s one of those toys that never seems to go out of style.
Bruder
And if you’re shopping for realistic vehicle toys, Bruder sets the benchmark. Their German-made trucks, loaders, and construction sets use non-toxic ABS plastic and meet both U.S. and EU safety standards. They’re pricey but worth every dollar — our Bruder Truck with JCB Loader has survived years of rough play and still looks new.
Final Verdict: Balance Is the Key
In the end, it’s not about choosing only wooden or only plastic — it’s about choosing well.
Choose mostly wooden toys for open-ended, creative, and calming play.
Add a few high-quality plastic toys for active, sensory, and STEM-based fun.
Always prioritize safety, sustainability, and your baby’s curiosity.
From my own experience — the toys that last, teach, and connect us are almost always wooden. But a few plastic favorites make life easier (and bath time more fun).
Comments